Everylot

Used Subaru Legacy under $40,000

48 listings from 36 dealer lots, $3,984 to $31,707 (median $21,403). 14 price drops this week. Cheapest first. Refine with filters

  1. 2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5 i Limited
    145,260 mi·Manual·AWD·Satin White PearlPlattners Punta Gorda Auto Max · Lehigh Acres, FL
    $3,984
  2. 2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium
    161,352 mi·AWD·Carbide Gray MetallicElder Ford of Tampa · Tampa, FL
    $7,169$8,071
    $902 price drop
  3. 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i
    121,502 mi·AWD·BlueYour Choice Autos - Crestwood · Crestwood, IL
    $7,999
  4. 2015 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited
    146,558 mi·AWD·RedYour Choice Autos - Joliet · Joliet, IL
    $10,376
  5. 2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited
    66,586 mi·AWD·Deep Indigo PearlSouthern 441 Toyota · Royal Palm Beach, FL
    $11,587
  6. 2019 Subaru Legacy Sedan
    93,923 mi·AWD·BLACKAuto House Of Bloomington · Bloomington, IL
    $13,495
  7. 2020 Subaru Legacy Sedan
    128,828 mi·AWD·BlueLandmark Ford Inc. · Springfield, IL
    $13,698$14,755
    $1,057 price drop
  8. 2024 Subaru Legacy Premium
    52,085 mi·AWD·WhiteAuto Gallery Jacksonville · Jacksonville, FL
    $15,288
  9. 2024 Subaru Legacy PREMIUM
    56,251 mi·4WD·Blackhgreg.com · Orlando, FL
    $16,302
  10. 2021 Subaru Legacy Premium
    54,292 mi·AWD·Abyss Blue PearlSarasota Toyota · Sarasota, FL
    $17,393$19,254
    $1,861 price drop
  11. 2025 Subaru Legacy BASE
    90,072 mi·AWD·Giy/SilverEd Morse Auto Group · Delray Beach, FL
    $17,700$18,500
    $800 price drop
  12. 2024 Subaru Legacy Base
    70,264 mi·AWD·BlackAuto Gallery Jacksonville · Jacksonville, FL
    $18,498$18,588
    $90 price drop
  13. 2024 Subaru Legacy PREMIUM
    22,019 mi·4WD·Grayhgreg.com · Palmetto Bay, FL
    $18,502
  14. 2022 Subaru Legacy Sedan
    77,685 mi·AWD·REDAuto House of Bloomington. 3 Currency Dr, Bloomington · Bloomington, IL
    $18,995
  15. 2021 Subaru Legacy LIMITED
    37,729 mi·4WD·Blackhgreg.com · Greenacres, FL
    $19,400
  16. 2023 Subaru Legacy Premium
    24,227 mi·AWD·Crystal Black SilicaDoral Acura · Miami, FL
    $20,492$20,538
    $46 price drop
  17. 2022 Subaru Legacy Premium
    58,616 mi·AWD·Ice SilverCoggin Honda of Orlando · Orlando, FL
    $20,531$21,309
    $778 price drop
  18. 2022 Subaru Legacy Premium
    88,700 mi·AWD·Brilliant Bronze MetallicLakeland Toyota · Lakeland, FL
    $20,542$21,468
    $926 price drop
  19. 2022 Subaru Legacy Limited
    81,593 mi·AWD·Crimson Red PearlUftring Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM · North Pekin, IL
    $20,702
  20. 2020 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Sport
    70,786 mi·AWD·BlackJidd Motors Mitsubishi · Des Plaines, IL
    $20,908
  21. 2024 Subaru Legacy Premium
    41,658 mi·AWD·SilverEd Morse Sawgrass Cadillac · Sunrise, FL
    $20,960$22,127
    $1,167 price drop
  22. 2022 Subaru Legacy Limited
    79,750 mi·AWD·Magnetite Gray MetallicCoral Springs Honda · Coral Springs, FL
    $21,061
  23. 2025 Subaru Legacy Limited
    8,785 mi·AWD·BlueAuto Gallery Jacksonville · Jacksonville, FL
    $21,195$21,295
    $100 price drop
  24. 2018 Subaru Legacy Limited
    35,266 mi·AWD·BlackAutoNation Ford Bradenton · Clearwater, FL
    $21,303
  25. 2024 Subaru Legacy LIMITED
    21,779 mi·4WD·Redhgreg.com · Palmetto Bay, FL
    $21,403
  26. 2024 Subaru Legacy Premium
    31,068 mi·FWD·Magnetite Gray MetallicToyota of Hollywood · Hollywood, FL
    $22,454
  27. 2025 Subaru Legacy Premium
    4,898 mi·AWD·WhiteAuto Gallery Jacksonville · Jacksonville, FL
    $22,997
  28. 2023 Subaru Legacy Limited
    28,338 mi·AWD·Crystal Black SilicaLehigh Acres Superstore · Lehigh Acres, FL
    $23,552
  29. 2023 Subaru Legacy Sport
    32,559 mi·AWD·Ice Silver MetallicVenice Toyota · Venice, FL
    $23,940$25,023
    $1,083 price drop
  30. 2023 Subaru Legacy Premium
    18,881 mi·AWD·Ice Silver MetallicDyer Auto · Vero Beach, FL
    $24,895
  31. 2025 Subaru Legacy Premium
    1,336 mi·AWD·Magnetite Gray MetallicSubaru of Melbourne · Melbourne, FL
    $24,900
  32. 2025 Subaru Legacy Premium
    22,590 mi·AWD·Crystal White PearlSchumacher Automotive Group · Delray Beach, FL
    $24,995
  33. 2024 Subaru Legacy Sport
    68,610 mi·AWD·SilverCoral Springs Buick GMC - Gm · Coral Springs, FL
    $25,123
  34. 2024 Subaru Legacy Sport
    40,560 mi·AWD·Magnetite Gray MetallicNapleton Buick GMC Crystal Lake · Crystal Lake, IL
    $25,899$27,019
    $1,120 price drop
  35. 2024 Subaru Legacy Limited
    16,244 mi·AWD·Crystal Black SilicaLincoln of Cutler Bay · Miami, FL
    $26,088
  36. 2024 Subaru Legacy Touring XT
    54,740 mi·AWD·Ice Silver MetallicNissan of Melbourne · Melbourne, FL
    $26,160$27,438
    $1,278 price drop

See every model: Used Subaru Legacy for sale.

We don't cover your area yet

Everylot indexes dealer lots state by state. Leave your email and we'll send one note the day your area is on. Nothing else, ever.

You're on the list

One email to you the day your area is covered. Nothing was created and nothing else will be sent.

Create your account

Free. Save cars and hear when their prices drop, on any device.

Loading secure sign-in

Already have an account? Sign in

By continuing you agree to the terms and privacy policy.